Research Question:
Do the 1930s HOLC redlining zones in Brooklyn continue to shape the spatial distribution of race and income in these areas today, particularly in East New York?
Background:
The Destruction of Black Spaces can be defined as the violent and systematic erasure of Black communities, neighborhoods, and cultural sites, often in the name of ‘urban renewal’. During the mid-twentieth century, the Home Owners’ Loan Corporation (HOLC) created “residential security maps” that classified neighborhoods by perceived investment risk. Areas with significant Black populations were systematically marked as “hazardous” (Grade D, colored red on maps)—a practice that became known as “redlining.”
Brooklyn’s East New York neighborhood exemplifies this pattern of systematic disinvestment. Once a thriving community, East New York was heavily redlined in the 1930s, setting in motion decades of spatial inequality that may persist to the present day.
Data & Setting:
This study analyzes Brooklyn (Kings County), New York, with particular focus on East New York—an area in eastern Brooklyn with high concentrations of D-grade (redlined) zones. Data sources include:
- HOLC Redlining Maps (1930s): Historical residential security maps from the Mapping Inequality project showing Grade A-D zones
- Census Time Series Data (1990-2020): Demographic and income data from the National Historical Geographic Information System (NHGIS)
- Race/ethnicity by census tract (1990, 2000, 2010, 2020)
- Median household income for corresponding periods
- Census tract boundaries for all four time periods
The study identified 161 census tracts in eastern Brooklyn where >25% of the tract area overlaps with historically redlined zones.
Methods:
This spatial analysis employs multiple GIS and spatial statistics techniques:
- Unary and binary geometric operations (st_within, st_union, st_intersects) to delineate areas of historical redlining and calculate spatial overlaps
- Measures of spatial autocorrelation including:
- Global Moran’s I to assess overall clustering patterns
- Local Indicators of Spatial Association (LISA) to identify specific clusters of racial and income patterns
- Monte Carlo simulations (999 iterations) to test whether observed spatial patterns differ significantly from random distributions
- Interactive mapping with Leaflet and ggplot2 to visualize how racialized urban policies align with contemporary demographic patterns
Intention:
The purpose of this analysis is to illuminate how racial injustice occurs spatially, particularly how the 1930s redlining of East New York has left a lasting mark on the geography of opportunity in Brooklyn. By uncovering the long-term spatial consequences of these interventions through formal hypothesis testing, this work aims to contribute to a deeper understanding of how historical acts of housing discrimination continue to shape patterns of segregation, income disparity, and neighborhood identity today.
By focusing on a single borough with detailed historical redlining data, this study provides a manageable yet thorough case study of redlining’s persistent spatial legacy.